Earn 9%–15% on Senior Secured Bonds.
Lower risk. Fixed returns. Start investing on Aspero with just ₹10,000.
Explore Bonds
Establishing a retirement portfolio becomes imperative for salaried individuals beyond a specific age, mainly to secure their financial future. The Indian government offers two savings opportunities, namely the National Pension Scheme (NPS) and the Public Provident Fund (PPF), designed to support such goals. Both these instruments serve as long-term savings solutions, providing tax benefits.
Keep reading this article to get a detailed insight towards the debate of NPS vs PPF and which is better for your financial goals.
What is the National Pension System or NPS?
Standing as a strong and regulated retirement savings plan, the National Pension System (NPS) offers people a structured path for long-term financial planning. NPS, which is overseen by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA), was created in response to the changing demands of the Indian populace in terms of retirement.
Some key features of NPS are as follows:
Investment Options
This feature of NPS includes a diverse array of investment alternatives, such as government funds, corporate bonds, equity funds, and alternative assets such as Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). Investors may customise their portfolios according to their financial objectives and risk tolerance thanks to the flexibility.
Two Tiers
Tier I and Tier II are the two operating tiers for NPS. The main pension account, known as Tier I, has withdrawal limitations that encourage long-term savings discipline. With more liquidity, Tier II functions as an optional savings facility that lets investors take money out whenever they need to.
Mandatory Annuity Purchase
To guarantee a consistent income stream in the post-retirement stage, at least 40% of the NPS corpus must be used to purchase an annuity at the time of retirement.
The tax benefits it provides individuals through its schemes are:
- Deduction Under Section 80C: Contributions to NPS are eligible for a deduction under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, up to a certain amount. Investors might take advantage of this to lower their taxable income.
- Additional Deduction under Section 80CCD(1B): Contributions paid to NPS are eligible for an extra deduction under Section 80CCD(1B) of up to a certain amount. This strengthens the scheme’s total tax-saving advantages.
What is a Public Provident Fund or PPF?
In India, the Public Provident Fund (PPF) is a government-backed savings programme designed to offer investors tax breaks and financial stability while promoting systematic long-term savings. The Public Provident Fund Act of 1968 governs the PPF, which is managed by the Department of Economic Affairs under the Ministry of Finance.
Some essential features of PPF to be aware of before investing are:
Government Support
The Indian government fully supports PPF, guaranteeing the security of the money deposited. PPF is a safe savings option that appeals to risk-averse investors in particular because of the governmental guarantee.
Fixed Interest Rate
The government sets the PPF interest rate every quarter, and the current rate is effective throughout the term of the investment. Because it provides a degree of stability to the returns, this fixed interest rate appeals to conservative investors.
Long-Term Lock-in Period
PPF encourages a disciplined approach to long-term savings with its 15-year lock-in period. However, starting with the seventh fiscal year, there are loan facilities and partial withdrawals available, giving some choices for liquidity.
When it comes to tax benefits of this tax-saving investment scheme, under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, contributions paid to the PPF are deductible, giving investors a way to lower their taxable income. Furthermore, both the interest generated and the maturity amount are free from income tax, as they are classified as EEE (Exempt, Exempt, Exempt).
What are the Key Differences Between NPS and PPF?
To understand NPS vs PPF in a detailed way, highlighting its benefits and taxation, check the table below.
To understand NPS vs PPF in a detailed way, highlighting its benefits and taxation, check the table below.
| Basis | NPS | PPF |
| Eligibility | An NPS account can be opened by Indian nationals between the ages of 18 and 60. | Eligible for any Indian residents. Also, a person can take advantage of tax benefits by opening a PPF account in the name of their minor children. |
| Maturity Period | The maturity period is negotiable. The NPS account takes contributions up to age 60, with the option to make further investments until age 70. | A PPF account has a 15-year maturity. Furthermore, this tenor may be extended by a block of five years following the fifteen-year mark, with or without further payments. |
| Rate of Interest | Approximately between 12% to 14%. | Approximately between 7% to 8%. |
| Benefits of Tax | Under Section 80CCD (1) of the IT Act, a tax credit is only available for up to Rs. 1.5 lakhs, and under Section 80CCD (2), it is only available for an additional Rs. 50,000, for a total of Rs. 2 lakhs. | Under Section 80 C, all PPF deposits are tax deductible. When the money is withdrawn, both the interest and the monies that were collected are tax-free. |
| Investment Limit | The minimum amount that must be contributed is Rs. There is no contribution maximum as long as your contributions stay below 10% of your gross yearly income, or 10% of your gross total income if you work for yourself. | A minimum of Rs. 500 annually, with a maximum of Rs. 1.5 lakhs. A maximum of twelve donations may be made annually. |
| Premature Withdrawals | Account holders may withdraw some or all of their money early and partially after ten years, subject to certain restrictions. However, investing at least 80% of the corpus in a life insurance annuity is needed to take an early retirement. | After the 7th year, withdrawals in part are permitted, but with restrictions. Loans are allowed between the third and sixth fiscal years following account establishment, subject to several restrictions. |
| Returns | The market affects interest rates. As a result, there are more potential advantages. | Government entities determine interest rates. |
| Choosing the Way to Invest Money | Fixed instruments like equity funds, other government securities, and government securities funds are your options. | No, you cannot choose in this case. |
| Annuity | Unless the maturity amount is less than Rs. 2 lakhs, you must purchase an annuity at maturity that is worth at least 40% of the corpus. | No option is available. |
Are There Any Similarities Between NPS and PPF?
Even though there are major differences between PPF and NPS, there are a few similarities between the two as well. Some of them are:
- The goal of both is to establish a retirement corpus.
- Both have tax advantages.
- These are long-term financial choices.
- Opening an account is necessary for both.
- Partial withdrawals are available from both.
- There is no tax on either the maturity corpus or returns.
Which is the Better Investment Option: NPS or PPF?
Considering both PPF vs NPS and their similarities, both options have specific features that can attract those interested in securing their retirement financially. However, the choice between the two depends on individual preferences, needs, and convenience.
For instance, if someone prefers lower risk, PPF is a better option, whereas NPS might be more appealing to those seeking higher returns, even with increased risk. Regarding life goals, NPS is preferable with fewer liabilities, while PPF is more suitable if savings are intended for a child’s education or marriage.
Final Words
To sum up, the decision between NPS vs PPF is based on personal risk tolerance and financial objectives. NPS is a good choice for people who don’t mind taking on a little risk because of its flexible withdrawal choices and market-linked potential. PPF, on the other hand, serves risk-averse investors looking for capital protection by providing guaranteed rates and government support.
Both are eligible for important Section 80C deductions, which facilitate tax planning. Make sure to analyse and use your present and future financial situations along with your future monetary plans before choosing a scheme to invest money.
Explore Fixed Income Academy to read more about fixed income investments